I'zaz Ali- Widely available, not too beneficial
Ghulam Mustapha- Best Hashiyah, availble from Dar ibn Kathir in Syria and Qadimi in Karachi Ash-Shihab- A contemporary Egyptian commentary, not very easily available At-Tashih wa at-Tarjih of Allamah Qasim- The Ilmiyyah edition is better than the Rayyan one. Sa'id bakdash is working on a muhaqqaq edition, however it might take some time to be released.
Bashar Bakri Arrabi is better than all other editions. First is hard to get, I used to sell copies of it, while the second is availble in Saudia etc Khulasah ad-Dalail- Old Qazan (Russian edition) better than the recent Maktabah ar-Rushd edition. Jawharah- The old Egyptian edition from Maktabah Khayriyyah, copied in Pakistan is the best edition, better than the Turkish one with Lubab in the margin and better than the Ilmiyyah edition. I am getting copies of all 3 in 2-3 weeks inshallah. Hashiyat at-Tahtawi ala al-Maraqi- No top editions, the Syrian one is probably better than the ilmiyyah one, while the old Egyptian edition isn't very user friendly. Maraqi al-Falah- Syrian edition as well, not the Ilmiyyah one. Imdad al-Fattah- the Syrian edition, not the Dar Ihya at-Turath one.
0 kommentar(er)
